Hulu and Disney+ have confirmed the Ryan Murphy legal drama will return for a second season, despite the show dividing opinion
22:19, 24 Nov 2025
The Kim Kardashian-led drama, All's Fair, has officially been given the green light for a second season, as announced by Hulu and Disney+ today (Monday, 24th November).
Despite its initial launch being met with a barrage of negative reviews, the series, masterminded by Ryan Murphy, premiered earlier this month and is set to conclude with a two-part finale on 9th December.
Even though it was met with a dismal 3 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes, it still managed to become Hulu's most successful premiere for an original scripted series and rocketed to the top spot on Disney+ in the UK.
The drama, which also stars Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Teyana Taylor, Glenn Close and Sarah Paulson, centres around a group of female divorce lawyers who break away from the norm and establish their own firm in a male-dominated industry.
The official synopsis for All's Fair reads: "Fierce, brilliant, and emotionally complicated, they navigate high-stakes breakups, scandalous secrets, and shifting allegiances - both in the courtroom and within their own ranks", reports the Express.
"In a world where money talks and love is a battleground, these women don't just play the game - they change it."
The decision to renew the series for a second season has sparked controversy, with many viewers criticising the show's performances and writing as some of the worst of the year.
However, it has also cultivated a dedicated cult following who have lauded the show's campy tone and self-aware comedy, earning it a more respectable 66 percent audience score on RT.
Viewers have flocked to social media to respond to All's Fair's renewal, and it's fair to say that reactions are divided.
One Reddit user commented: "I honestly think this show could be somewhat watchable if they had literally anyone else in the lead. Kim Kardashian just cannot act at all, and it's so jarringly obvious when she's in scenes with seasoned professionals like Glenn Close, Niecy Nash, Sarah Paulson, and Naomi Watts.
"It's almost like you can see them trying to force the tiniest bit of emotion or response from her that isn't completely wooden. And as a viewer, any time she's on screen is just absolutely painful to witness. I truly think people are just hate watching the show at this point, or they're just complete masochists."
Another disheartened viewer confessed they had great expectations but ceased watching after merely three episodes.
"I think some wittier writers could come in and this could be a total jam," they said. "I wanted it to be fun. I was in for camp. I wasn't looking for excellence... but boy it wasn't even enjoyable enough to warrant watching for me.
"Honestly gutted. The trailers looked fab and I was pretty excited for this."
Get Disney+ for 24p a day
This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more
Disney+ has announced that it will up its annual subscription by 10% on September 30. Until then, shoppers can still lock into its £89.90 annual plan, which works out less than 30p a day.
The discussion carried on across X where one user raged: "Not even trying to be a hater bc the cast is epic but Alls Fair is quite literally unwatchably bad."
However, there are numerous supporters who are thrilled to witness the drama unfold, with one declaring: "All the hate on all's fair is crazy!!
"Maybe I'm just getting older and I love to see women taking their power back, standing up for themselves, empowering each other, protecting their self, and own peace cuz that's the point I am in my life. Besides the bad acting I like it!"
Have you been tuning in or giving the series a wide berth?
All's Fair continues Tuesdays on Disney+.